Critical friend, Blog

What are academic researchers for?

Hilary Sutcliffe

4 Jan 2017

We are helping a University and some academic researchers explore how their areas of work make a greater contribution to society.  We began to narrow the focus to consider how they can work ‘for’ the particular areas of society they serve, than just their work being ‘about’ them - actively contributing rather than only dispassionately observing.

 

Here are my starting points, and thanks to Helen Pallett and Roland Jackson on twitter for contributing to this list and Duncan Green from Oxfam for his enjoyable blogs on why academics can help NGOs.

 

Perhaps an academic can contribute to society through:

  • Dispassionately observing phenomena?
  • Providing an independent or impartial view?
  • Delivering rigorous evidence?
  • Providing space for others to reflect on key issues?
  • Questioning things taken for granted?
  • Challenging assumptions?
  • Creating new technologies, products, services or systems?
  • Developing new ways of thinking or working?
  • Providing access to funding for important work with others?
  • Helping us understand ourselves better?
  • Helping shed light on how different perspectives or ways of thinking can help us as individuals or organisations more effective?

These are not all comparable, some are values others might be actions, but they have provided real food for thought for the researchers and a useful starting point for discussions about Responsible Innovation and Universities.   

 

COMMENTS

 

From University of Nottingham Academic Prof Brigitte Nerlich

 

As comments on twitter quickly vanish… I once wrote something about scholarship, or rather reported on older research into the value of scholarship which might be of interest. And just replace scholarship by ‘academic research’ and ‘scholar’ by academic, if scholarship seems to old fashioned a word.

 

This is based on a report entitled ‘Scholarship reconsidered‘Scholarship reconsidered: priorities of the professoriate‘ – for hyperlinks please look here:
https://blogs.nottingham.ac.uk/makingsciencepublic/2013/11/02/on-the-value-of-scholarship/

 

“Ernest Leroy Boyer (1928 – 1995) was an American educator who served as Commissioner of Education. Throughout his life he fostered reforms in teaching and education and closer relationship between teaching and research. In this process he also redefined the concept of ‘scholarship’. Boyer “proposed that ‘scholarship’ should be seen as covering four types of activity within a modern and engaged university:

The scholarship of discovery that includes original research that advances knowledge;

The scholarship of integration that involves synthesis of information across disciplines, across topics within a discipline, or across time;

 

The scholarship of application (also later called the scholarship of engagement) that goes beyond the service duties of a faculty member to those within or outside the University and involves the rigor and application of disciplinary expertise with results that can be shared with and/or evaluated by peers; and

The scholarship of teaching and learning that the systematic study of teaching and learning processes. It differs from scholarly teaching in that it requires a format that will allow public sharing and the opportunity for application and evaluation by others.” (emphasis added)

 

This model of ‘scholarship’ gives equal weight to the creation of knowledge, the integration of knowledge and the making sense of knowledge in context(s), the making use of knowledge in the wider world, with the wider world and for the wider world, and the interaction and transformation of knowledge through collaborative teaching and learning.

 

The first and second types of scholarship can be said to ‘make public knowledge’ and the third and forth to ‘make knowledge public’. Both these wider activities are interrelated and can’t be carried out in isolation. There is however a tendency to pull these activities apart in the context of reorganising the (public) funding of teaching and research both in the US and the UK.”

 

Cheers
Brigitte

 

From Director of the Risk Innovation Lab at ASU Prof Andrew Maynard:

Ah, a nice provocative question for a Sunday morning :)

 

There are, of course, plenty of well-worn answers to the question that can be parroted off (usually starting with the “self-evident” truth that academics are essential, then back-filling the “why” and “how”), but it’s a surprisingly tough question to answer with reflection and honesty.

 

I typically think of my roles and my responsibilities as an academic as a generator and conveyor of knowledge and insights that have value to society (or more specific, parts of society) by enriching lives (opening up ways of seeing and understanding self, community and the world more generally that are life-enhancing), informing (providing information and insights that helps people make decisions and create “value” for themselves and their community), and educating (providing people with specific knowledge and expertise that they can use effectively).

 

These roles may sound very one-way, but I also think they come with a great responsibility to listen to, engage with and learn from social constituents, so you (I) as an academic become a responsible partner within society who is contributing to social well-being and growth. I guess tis is part of the largely unwritten contract between academics and society.

 

In a more practical note, here are three resources to kick things off, that might be useful:

1. It’s worth looking at the eight design aspirations of ASU (https://newamericanuniversity.asu.edu/about/design-aspirations), which map out a framework for socially responsive and beneficial academic research and practice. I find this a very powerful framework for testing whether academic activities are socially useful, or merely self-indulgent.

 

2. There’s also the idea of the honest broker that Roger Pielke Junior described – http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/publications/special/honest_broker/

 

3. And although it’s academics talking to academics, it’s worth checking out this summary of a meeting at the University of Michigan on Academic Engagement in Public and Political Discourse – http://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/mm/

 

These are just for starters…

Comments

cialis information cialis vs levitra new posts
[url=http://viagrawithoutdoctorpres.com]viagra without a doctor prescription[/url] cialis vs cialis vs levitra which is better msboard.cgi?id=
viagra without a doctor prescription - like cialis for heart help that ins pays
cialis for daily use prices website

viagra online yabb
[url=http://viagrawithoutdoctorprescr.com]viagra without a doctor prescription[/url] india viagra manufacturers
viagra without a doctor prescription - buy viagra online most users ever online was
ajanta direct, viagra,

cialis 20mg side effects jump to
[url=http://cialis-walmart.shop]generic cialis at walmart
[/url] info cialis
cialis at walmart
- cialis the team
cialis quick

viagra testimonials treatment clever.cgi?mode=
[url=http://viagrawithoutdoctorpres.net]viagra without prescription
[/url] opinion effects of viagra
viagra without a doctor prescription
- .edu.ar moodle user viagra
buy viagra now from $1 53 get 12 bonus pills free

viagra v viagra review
[url=http://viagrawithoutdoctorpharm.com]viagra without a doctor prescription usa
[/url] viagra ik
viagra without a doctor prescription usa
- viagra and alcohol side effects last post
viagra 20mg pills jump to

online casino bonus slots for real money betfair online casino [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]play casino[/url]

casino bonus casino blackjack online casino real money [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]online casino slots[/url]

play casino casino blackjack real money casino [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]real money casino[/url]

play casino casino online casino blackjack [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]online casinos for us players[/url]

mgm online casino online casinos casino online [url=https://onlinecasinolc.com/]casino online[/url]

online gambling casino online usa online casino [url=https://onlinecasinogamestt.us.org/]online casinos[/url]

betfair online casino casino play slots for real money [url=https://onlinecasinogamesnt.us.org/]free online casino slots[/url]

online casino real money betfair online casino best online casinos | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]casino play[/url]

slots for real money online casinos for us players online gambling [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]online casino slots[/url]

casino slots casino online best online casinos [url=https://onlinecasinolc.com/]casino slots[/url]

online casinos for us players casino games bovada casino [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]casino real money[/url]

online casino games casino slots casino online [url=https://onlinecasinolc.com/]gsn casino[/url]

mgm online casino usa online casino casino games [url=https://onlinecasinogamestt.us.org/]online casino games[/url]

online casino games gsn casino online casino bonus [url=https://onlinecasinogamesnt.us.org/]online casino gambling[/url]

bovada casino slots for real money online casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinogamestt.us.org/]gsn casino games[/url]

casino bonus best online casino slots for real money [url=https://onlinecasinogamesnt.us.org/]online casino slots[/url]

online casinos casino slots online casinos | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]casino play[/url]

online gambling slots for real money play casino | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]bovada casino[/url]

casino play best online casinos casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinolc.com/]online casino gambling[/url]

online gambling casino gsn casino casino bonus [url=https://casinoslotssy.us.org/]online casino bonus[/url]

online casino gambling casino slots online casinos [url=https://casinoslotsy.us.org/]best online casino[/url]

betfair online casino casino bonus online casinos | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]best online casino[/url]

best online casinos gsn casino games online casinos for us players [url=https://casinoslotsy.us.org/]gsn casino slots[/url]

online casinos for us players online casino gambling online casino real money [url=https://casinoslotssy.us.org/]online gambling casino[/url]

online casino games online gambling play casino [url=https://casinoslotssy.us.org/]online casino slots[/url]

online casino games online casino gambling casino play [url=https://casinoslotsy.us.org/]casino bonus[/url]

online casino real money slots for real money online casinos | [url=https://onlinecasinovus.com/]casino play[/url]

online gambling casino online casino games bovada casino [url=https://onlinecasinoslotsparty.com/]bovada casino[/url]

online casino real money usa online casino play casino [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]best online casino[/url]

gsn casino games casino slots casino bonus | [url=https://onlinecasinovus.com/]usa online casino[/url]

bovada casino gsn casino games best online casino | [url=https://onlinecasinovus.com/]best online casino[/url]

casino online online casino usa online casino [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]online casino gambling[/url]

online gambling casino casino slots online casinos [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]real money casino[/url]

free online casino slots online casino online casino real money [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]casino online[/url]

casino slots free online casino slots slots for real money [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]free online casino slots[/url]

online casino casino games casino blackjack [url=https://onlinecasinoslotsparty.com/]online casino[/url]

online casino games casino slots casino real money [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]online casino games[/url]

online casino games mgm online casino casino play [url=https://onlinecasinoslotsparty.com/]bovada casino[/url]

mgm online casino betfair online casino mgm online casino [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]gsn casino games[/url]

casino blackjack bovada casino casino play [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]play casino[/url]

online gambling casino online best online casino [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]play casino[/url]

online gambling online casino slots usa online casino [url=https://onlinecasinogamestt.us.org/]free online casino slots[/url]

best online casinos free online casino slots casino play [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]casino play[/url]

casino games bovada casino bovada casino [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]online casino bonus[/url]

casino slots gsn casino games casino blackjack | [url=https://onlinecasinozonee.com/]online casinos[/url]

casino slots casino online online gambling [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]gsn casino[/url]

mgm online casino online casino online casino games [url=https://onlinecasinolc.com/]mgm online casino[/url]

gsn casino games gsn casino casino games [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]gsn casino games[/url]

gsn casino games online casino games online casino bonus [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]online gambling casino[/url]

casino play best online casino casino real money | [url=https://onlinecasinoppl.com/]slots for real money[/url]

gsn casino play casino gsn casino games [url=https://onlinecasinormoney.com/]casino games[/url]

casino online online casinos gsn casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinormoney.com/]gambling sites[/url]

online gambling casino gsn casino games casino bonus [url=https://casinoslotssy.us.org/]casino blackjack[/url]

bovada casino gambling sites usa online casino [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]online casino games[/url]

online casino bonus online gambling best online casino | [url=https://onlinecasinoppl.com/]best online casinos[/url]

casino play online casino games online casino games | [url=https://onlinecasinoppl.com/]casino slots[/url]

online casinos casino blackjack play casino | [url=https://onlinecasinomaniaa.com/]casino slots[/url]

online casino bonus casino real money online casino games | [url=https://onlinecasinomaniaa.com/]gsn casino games[/url]

casino real money bovada casino casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinoslotsparty.com/]play casino[/url]

online gambling casino slots online casino slots | [url=https://onlinecasinozeus24.com/]online casinos for us players[/url]

gsn casino online casino games casino play | [url=https://onlinecasinozeus24.com/]casino slots[/url]

online casinos online casino games play casino [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]bovada casino[/url]

online casino games free online casino slots usa online casino [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]slots for real money[/url]

gsn casino games best online casino online casinos [url=https://onlinecasinog24.com/]gsn casino games[/url]

online casino bonus online gambling online casino [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]betfair online casino[/url]

play casino play casino casino blackjack [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]online casinos[/url]

bovada casino gambling sites gambling sites [url=https://onlinecasinolo.com/]online casino real money[/url]

casino blackjack online casinos play casino [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]casino blackjack[/url]

play casino online casinos slots for real money | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]best online casino[/url]

casino real money casino games gambling sites [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]online casinos[/url]

bovada casino online casino games online casino gambling [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]gambling sites[/url]

casino slots casino games gsn casino games [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]real money casino[/url]

usa online casino bovada casino casino real money | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]real money casino[/url]

gsn casino online casino games gsn casino games [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]online casino games[/url]

gsn casino slots online casinos for us players mgm online casino [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]best online casinos[/url]

casino games online casino bonus usa online casino | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]casino bonus[/url]

online casino games gsn casino slots casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]gsn casino[/url]

online casino games betfair online casino online casinos [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]online casino real money[/url]

casino slots online casino slots free online casino slots [url=https://onlinecasinoster.us.org/]online gambling casino[/url]

online casinos online casinos for us players usa online casino | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]online gambling casino[/url]

online casinos online casinos for us players play casino [url=https://onlinecasinorealmoney.us.org/]betfair online casino[/url]

mgm online casino betfair online casino casino blackjack | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]real money casino[/url]

play casino gsn casino games casino bonus | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]mgm online casino[/url]

online casino bonus casino games online casinos for us players | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]online casinos for us players[/url]

casino online online gambling casino real money | [url=https://onlinecasinowus.com/]online casino games[/url]

Add new comment